Thursday, February 4, 2016

Pipeline Inspection

Pipeline Inspection
In the United States, millions of miles of pipeline carrying everything from water to crude oil. The pipe is vulnerable to attack by internal and external corrosion, cracking, third party damage and manufacturing flaws. If a pipeline carrying water springs a leak bursts, it can be a problem but it usually doesn't harm the environment. However, if a petroleum or chemical pipeline leaks, it can be a environmental disaster. More information on recent US pipeline accidents can be found at the, National Transportation Safety Board's Internet site. In an attempt to keep pipelines operating safely, periodic inspections are performed to find flaws and damage before they become cause for concern.
When a pipeline is built, inspection personnel may use visual, X-ray, magnetic particle, ultrasonic and other inspection methods to evaluate the welds and ensure that they are of high quality. The image to the left show two NDT technicians setting up equipment to perform an X-ray inspection of a pipe weld. These inspections are performed as the pipeline is being constructed so gaining access the inspection area is not problem. In some areas like Alaska, sections of pipeline are left above ground like shown above, but in most areas they get buried. Once the pipe is buried, it is undesirable to dig it up for any reason.
So, how do you inspect a buried pipeline?
Have you ever felt the ground move under your feet? If you're standing in New York City, it may be the subway train passing by. However, if you're standing in the middle of a field in Kansas it may be a pig passing under your feet. Huh??? Engineers have developed devices, called pigs, that are sent through the buried pipe to perform inspections and clean the pipe. If you're standing near a pipeline, vibrations can be felt as these pigs move through the pipeline. The pigs are about the same diameter of the pipe so they range in size from small to huge. The pigs are carried through the pipe by the flow of the liquid or gas and can travel and perform inspections over very large distances. They may be put into the pipe line on one end and taken out at the other. The pigs carry a small computer to collect, store and transmit the data for analysis. In 1997, a pig set a world record when it completed a continuous inspection of the Trans Alaska crude oil pipeline, covering a distance of 1,055 km in one run. 
Pigs use several nondestructive testing methods to perform the inspections. Most pigs use a magnetic flux leakage method but some also use ultrasound to perform the inspections. The pig shown to the left and below uses magnetic flux leakage. A strong magnetic field is established in the pipe wall using either magnets or by injecting electrical current into the steel. Damaged areas of the pipe can not support as much magnetic flux as undamaged areas so magnetic flux leaks out of the pipe wall at the damaged areas. An array of sensor around the circumference of the pig detects the magnetic flux leakage and notes the area of damage. Pigs that use ultrasound, have an array of transducers that emits a high frequency sound pulse perpendicular to the pipe wall and receives echo signals from the inner surface and the outer surface of the pipe. The tool measures the time interval between the arrival of a reflected echos from inner surface and outer surface to calculate the wall thickness.
On some pipelines it is easier to use remote visual inspection equipment to assess the condition of the pipe. Robotic crawlers of all shapes and sizes have been developed to navigate the pipe. The video signal is typically fed to a truck where an operator reviews the images and controls the robot.













Sumber: https://www.nde-ed.org/AboutNDT/SelectedApplications/PipelineInspection/PipelineInspection.htm



Pipeline Commissioning

Pipeline commissioning: purging air with gas

Phillip Venton.
Phillip Venton.
When gas pipelines were in their infancy in Australia, it was common practice to displace air from the pipeline using gas.
Since nitrogen is used in process industries to displace air from process vessels and complex piping prior to introducing a flammable gas, people in the pipeline industry thought more about the risk and it became more common to separate the air from the gas using a large slug of an inert gas such as nitrogen.
This introduced significant complexity into the operation, requiring large tankers of liquid nitrogen, vaporising equipment and fuel to be transported to very remote locations.
Mechanical separation (a pig), is an alternative, but rarely used because the velocity during a purge is usually too high.
A few pipelines such as the Moomba to Wilton pipeline were left filled with water following construction.
The water was displaced using gas to propel a relatively complex pig train to separate the water and gas.
The effort to dry the pipeline was considerable and this approach has rarely been used since.
When it became necessary to introduce gas into the 800 km long Eastern Gas Pipeline (EGP) a range of options were considered, including; nitrogen slugs, a separating pig train and a return to the early practice of simply displacing the air with gas.
The review concluded that the quickest, simplest and safest approach was to displace the air with gas.
The operation was successful, and subsequently a similar approach was used on the Tasmanian Gas Pipeline and the SEA Gas Pipeline.
More recently, pipeline commissioning has reverted to using an inert gas slug to separate the air and gas.
While this approach may have been appropriate for those pipelines, there are concerns that the simple gas purge approach is not considered because of a basic lack of understanding of the process, and indeed the potential ignition risk.
This article uses the EGP purge process as an example that purging air without the complexity of an inert gas slug, or mechanical separation of air and gas with a pig, is a safe and predictable process.
AGA Purging Principles and Practice
Research undertaken by the Gas Research Institute (GRI) was published in 1997 (GRI-97/0104 Pipeline Purging Principles and Practices Research) together with a software application, PURGE.EXE, designed to model the purge process.
The EGP commissioning team used both this report and PURGE.EXE in evaluating options for purging air from the pipeline.
Much of the GRI research was incorporated into the 2001 revision of the AGA Purging Principles and Practice.
The research was undertaken by South West Research Institute (SWRI) (this report is still available from the Gas Technology Institute, although unfortunately the PURGE.EXE application, developed for Windows XP, appears to no longer be available).
Ignition risk
The risk that the gas-air mixture at the purge interface ignites (explosively) within the pipe is often quoted as the reason for separating the gas and air with an inert gas slug.
In new, steel pipelines this risk is vanishingly small because there is no ignition source in the pipeline.
There may be a small risk in an existing pipeline containing pyrophoric dust.
The SWRI research concluded that in the unlikely event of interface ignition, the maximum overpressure in the pipe is approximately 10 times the pressure in the pipe at the time of ignition – for this reason the AGA Purging Principles document recommends limiting the maximum pressure in the pipe during a gas purge to 100 psig (thus limiting the maximum pressure should combustion occur to ~1,000 psig, the typical maximum pipeline pressure in North America at the date of the research).
This can be readily confirmed by calculating the volume change when methane is burnt, using the equation 
CH4 + 2O2 = CO2 + 2H2O.
The plume ignition risk is also low, provided simple safety procedures are followed.
Moreover, the high plume velocity at the vent provides momentum to propel the plume above most credible ignition sources (like the vent from a pipeline blowdown).
Hydraulics – the length of the mixed air-gas interface
There are two distinct flow regimes within a pipeline – laminar flow, which is characterised by a parabolic velocity profile across the pipeline cross section, and turbulent flow, which is characterised by a constant velocity profile across the pipe cross section, except for a thin boundary layer at the pipe wall where the velocity transitions to zero at the wall.
In laminar flow, the fluid in the central region moves at a higher velocity than that in the outer region, causing continuous longitudinal mixing of the pipe contents.
In turbulent flow the essentially constant velocity profile prevents longitudinal mixing.
There is a minor mixing at the batch interface resulting from a combination of dispersion across the interface, and from the velocity change in the boundary layer.
The interface volume can be calculated from the pipeline flow and product properties, while the constant velocity profile enables the interface position to be accurately tracked from the flow rate.
This phenomena is used in many multi-product pipelines to separate batches of different products, eliminating the need to provide positive separation using, for example, batching pigs.
In a multi-product pipeline, the batches are usually sequenced so that mixed interface fluid can be blended into the following uncontaminated batch without degrading it.
Various publications discuss prediction of the interface length in liquids pipelines – these provide useful background to understanding the phenomena.
Similar concepts apply to the interface length calculation for gases, although the velocity (Reynolds number) variation during the purge increase the calculation complexity.
These methods incorporate an estimate of the interphase dispersion along the travel length.
Eastern Gas Pipeline Purge example
Gas was used to purge the Eastern Gas Pipeline (DN 450), a continuous operation between the inlet compressor station at Longford and an intermediate station at Kembla Grange, a distance of 713 km.
Once gas was received, the Kembla Grange vent isolation valve was closed and the pipeline packing operation followed.
The purge operation was designed using the principles and recommendations from GRI-97/0104 Pipeline Purging Principles and Practices Research.
Additional modelling was undertaken using WINFLOW/WINTRAN hydraulic modelling software, licensed to Duke Energy.
The initial study concluded that the additional complexity introduced using a nitrogen slug to separate the air and gas was not justified by the ignition or operational risk – and neither was the use of a batching pig train.
Consequently, design effort concentrated on developing a gas purge procedure.
For purging the pipeline using gas, the key principles are:
The purge gas flow must be continuous:
1. Continuous purge flow is essential when purging with gas – if the gas flow is lost, the mixed gas-air interface volume increases rapidly, primarily through buoyancy driven mixing 
(gas density is approximately half that of air).
For this purge operation, gas supply was assessed as being secure since it was drawn from the Longford Gas Plant delivery pipeline used to supply the Victorian market. Had there been a concern about the supply reliability, the purge design may have been changed to use either positive separation with a pig, or a slug of inert gas.
2. The maximum pressure should not exceed 10 per cent of the pipeline maximum allowable operation pressure (MAOP).
Simulation studies were undertaken to assess the purge performance using controls recommended from the research, namely:
  • Purge at constant inlet pressure; and,
  • Purge at constant inlet flow.
The constant pressure approach was discarded because the gas supplier advised that the variable flow required through the purge operation was not desirable, and it was considered more difficult to control than simply maintaining a constant flow.
It was decided to vent air at the Mila and Oallen scraper stations (kP291 and kP564 respectively).
This limited the volume of gas mixture discharged at Kembla Grange, while limiting the pipeline pressure and allowing physical tracking of the interface.
The purge process commenced with the pipeline isolation valves at Kembla Grange, Oallen and Mila stations closed, and the pipeline vent valve at Mila open.
Gas was introduced at Longford, and the flow adjusted to 15,000 scm/h (and adjusted as required).
Commissioning staff were located at the Mila vent, equipped with gas detectors.
Once detected, the gas concentration in the vent was monitored until the mixed interface was discharged.
The vent valve was closed and pipeline isolation valve opened, together with the vent valve at Oallen.
The process was repeated until gas was received at Kembla Grange.
The pipeline purge was completed in 32.5 hours.
Once gas was received, the vent valve was closed and gas flow increased to pack the pipeline with the linepack needed to sustain the intended flow rate.
The application PURGE.EXE developed by SWRI is limited to a pipeline length of 999,999 feet, requiring it to be used iteratively. 
Figures 2 to 6 show the output from the purge simulation at an inlet flow of 15,000 scm/h for the 291 km pipeline section between Longford and Mila.
The calculation predicts the mixed gas volume is approximately 5000 ft3 and approximately 5100 ft long, while the prediction shows that the pipeline velocity at the time that the mixed volume reaches the vent is approximately 40 ft/s.
From this, the time for the mixed gas-air volume (from 100 per cent air to 100 per cent gas) to be discharged through the pipeline vent is approximately 127 seconds (2.1 minutes).
Figure 7 presents pressure data taken from supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) during the purge, together with the prediction from the SWRI application PURGE.EXE.
The following notes:
  • The SCADA pressure measurement at Mila and Oallen did not report pressures higher than 50 kPa (a commissioning error).
  • The Mila pressure shows a relatively large pressure drop after gas arrival, once the vent valve is closed and the mainline valve at that site is opened. The effect is reflected at each other measurement point. The effect was not seen at Oallen, probably because of this instrument error.
  • The interface arrival time at Mila predicted by the PURGE application (Figure 5) is 700 minutes (11.67 hours). Gas arrived at Mila 11.62 hours after the purge commencing.
  • The PURGE application requires a reasonable estimate of the pipeline roughness to reasonably reflect the actual flow. The EGP was a new pipeline, and the construction team applied considerable effort in the drying and cleaning phase to burnish the inner pipe surface. The predicted arrival time assumed a pipe roughness of 20 microns.
  • Gas concentration was assessed using portable detectors set to monitor nitrogen (not methane). Gas arrival was reported at the time that the nitrogen concentration started to drop, and 100 per cent gas was reported at the time that the nitrogen concentration was essentially zero. The instruments did not provide data logging capability, so the recorded data reflects human and sampling errors.
  • At Mila, 100 per cent gas was reported eight minutes after it was first detected (longer than the 2.1 minutes predicted from the PURGE application). Records at Oallen indicate that the time between first and 100 per cent gas was 15 minutes (unreasonably high, and probably reflects the time taken to complete the valve changeover).
Conclusion – EGP Purge
The EGP purge showed conclusively that, provided a constant gas flow can be guaranteed for the duration of the purge, purging air from a pipeline using gas is simple, predictable and, above all, safe.
It showed that the model PURGE.EXE provided an accurate prediction of the hydraulics during the purge process, and a good estimate of the mixed air-gas volume to be discharged.
This methodology was subsequently used successfully to purge and pack the onshore Tasmanian Gas Pipeline sections and the SEA Gas pipeline.
Purge Planning – Future Pipelines
As mentioned earlier, the application PURGE.EXE is no longer available with the SWRI report, and GRI has advised that there is no intention to revise it for current desktop operating systems.
(Note: The writer is attempting to determine whether SWRI is prepared to update the application).
Transient gas hydraulics applications can be used to predict the interface arrival time provided the model used is carefully developed with an understanding of the computational methodology of the application.
Table 1 illustrates predictions from the application used by the writer (FLOWTRAN) for the Longford-Mila pipe section.
Two purge options are considered to assess the application’s capacity to predict the arrival of the first gas, and purge of the last of the nitrogen:
  • The pipe was filled with a simulated air mixture at atmospheric pressure and purged with a typical Longford gas.
  • The pipe was filled with nitrogen, and purged with methane.
The calculated first gas arrival shown in the table is the time that the nitrogen concentration falls by 2 per cent from the pre-purge concentration, and the ‘all gas’ arrival is the time that the calculated nitrogen concentration falls to 2 per cent.
The purge was also tracked using the ‘pig tracking’ option in the application, assuming zero slip.
The table shows:
  • The pig tracking option provides a good prediction of the arrival of the mid-point in the air-gas mixture when a simulated air mixture is purged with a typical gas mixture. Purging nitrogen with methane under-predicts the mixture arrival time.
  • The model significantly over-predicts the mixture volume (approximately 100 minutes, compared with 8-10 minutes). Other transient hydraulic models may calculate the mixture differently and give different results.
  • More calculation nodes did not significantly change the predicted arrival time, except that the model with 308 nodes did not calculate the ‘pig’ arrival time.
Conclusion
Purging a new pipeline (or refilling a section of an existing pipeline) using gas without an inert slug or mechanical separation, is a safe and predictable operation which reduces the cost and complexity of the activity.
Transient hydraulic models can be used with care to reasonably predict the arrival time of the gas-air mixture, although they may not provide a reliable estimate of the mixture volume that must be purged.
Designers using these tools should carefully evaluate the model predictions.
Those who have access to an application that can execute Windows XP executable files can also use PURGE.EXE to support the prediction.
Notes:
1. The fully turbulent (plug) flow for this pipe requires a velocity of approximately 1 m/s.
2. The predicted pipeline velocity at the end of the DN 450 pipe section (40 ft/s) suggests that the plume velocity from the DN150 vent will be in the order of 100 m/s – providing significant momentum to propel the mixed air-gas interface well beyond ignition sources.
Sumber: http://pipeliner.com.au/news/pipeline_commissioning_purging_air_with_gas/92260

Pipeline Decommissioning

How Does Decommissioning Work?


Decommissioning oil and gas installations can cost operators an average of $4-$10 million in the shallow water Gulf of Mexico. Thus when the US Department of the Interior Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, Regulation, and Enforcement (BOEMRE) Gulf of Mexico OCS Region issued a new decommissioning regulation in September 2010, operators knew they'd take a hit.
NTL 2010-G05 requires wells that have not been used for the last five years to be to be permanently abandoned, temporarily abandoned, or zonally isolated within 3 years after Oct. 15, 2010. If wells are zonally isolated, operators have 2 additional years to permanently or temporarily abandon the wellhead. Plus, platforms and supporting infrastructure that have been idle for five or more years must be removed within 5 years as of the Oct. 15, 2010 effective date.
This new NTL on top of the typical volume of decommissioning work in the GOM will increase demand for contractors and, in turn, their dayrates.
According to a BOEMRE statement, the MMS (former name of the BOEMRE) conducted an Alternative Internal Control Review (AICR) of idle structures and wells on active leases in the GOM OCS in 2008. The review identified a significant number of idle platforms that need to be permanently plugged and removed. Why? Idle structures and wells could be damaged in a hurricane and cause an environmental disaster. Plus, damaged platforms and wells cost more to decommission than non-damaged wells.
How Is An Offshore Rig Decommissioned?
There are 10 steps to the process: Project Management, Engineering and Planning; Permitting and Regulatory Compliance; Platform Preparation; Well Plugging and Abandonment; Conductor Removal; Mobilization and Demobilization of Derrick Barges; Platform Removal; Pipeline and Power Cable Decommissioning; Materials Disposal; and Site Clearance. Each step is discussed below.
Project Management
Project management, engineering and planning for decommissioning an offshore rig usually starts three years before the well runs dry. The process involves:
  • review of contractual obligations
  • engineering analysis
  • operational planning
  • contracting
Due to the limited number of derrick barges, many operators contract these vessels two to three years in advance. In addition, much of the decommissioning process requires contractors who specialize in a specific part of the process. Most operators will contract out project management, cutting, civil engineering, and diving services.
Permitting And Regulatory Compliance
Obtaining permits to decommission an offshore rig can take up to three years to complete. Often, operators will contract a local consulting firm to ensure that all permits are in order prior to decommissioning. Local consulting firms are familiar with the regulatory framework of their region.
An Execution Plan is one of the first steps in the process. Included in this plan is environmental information and field surveys of the project site. The plan describes a schedule of decommissioning activities and the equipment and labor required to carry out the operation. An execution plan is required to secure permits from Federal, State, and local regulatory agencies. The BOEMRE will also analyze the environmental impact of the project and recommend ways to eliminate or minimize those impacts.
Federal agencies often involved in decommissioning projects include BOEMRE, National Marine Fisheries Service, US Army Corps of Engineers, US Fish and Wildlife Service, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, US Environmental Protection Agency, US Coast Guard, and the US Department of Transportation, Office of Pipeline Safety.
Platform Preparation
To prepare a platform for decommissioning, tanks, processing equipment and piping must be flushed and cleaned and residual hydrocarbons have to be disposed of; platform equipment has to be removed, which includes cutting pipe and cables between deck modules, separating the modules, installing padeyes to lift the modules; and reinforcing the structure. Underwater, workers prepare the jacket facilities for removal, which includes removing marine growth.
Well Plugging And Abandonment
Plugging and abandonment is one of the major costs of a decommissioning project and can be broken into two phases.
The planning phase of well plugging includes:
  • data collection
  • preliminary inspection
  • selection of abandonment methods
  • submittal of an application for BOEMRE approval
In the GOM, the rig-less method, which was developed in the 1980s, is primarily used for plugging and abandonment jobs. The rig-less method uses a load spreader on top of a conductor, which provides a base to launch tools, equipment and plugs downhole.
Well abandonment involves:
  • well entry preparations
  • use of a slick line unit
  • filling the well with fluid
  • removal of downhole equipment
  • cleaning out the wellbore
  • plugging open-hole and perforated intervals(s) at the bottom of the well
  • plugging casing stubs
  • plugging of annular space
  • placement of a surface plug
  • placement of fluid between plugs
Plugs must be tagged to ensure proper placement or pressure-tested to verify integrity.
Conductor Removal
According to BOEMRE, all platform components including conductor casings must be removed to at least 15 ft below the ocean floor or to a depth approved by the Regional Supervisor based upon the type of structure or ocean-bottom conditions.
To remove conductor casing, operators can chose one of three procedures:
  1. Severing, which requires the use of explosive, mechanical or abrasive cutting
  2. Pulling/sectioning, which uses the casing jacks to raise the conductors that are unscrewed or cut into 40 ft-long segments.
  3. Offloading, which utilizes a rental crane to lay down each conductor casing segment in a platform staging area, offloading sections to a boat, and offloading at a port. The conductors are then transported to an onshore disposal site.
Mobilization/Demobilization And Platform Removal
Mobilization and demobilization of derrick barges is a key component in platform removal. According to BOEMRE, platforms, templates and pilings must be removed to at least 15 ft below the mudlline.
First, the topsides are taken apart and lifted onto the derrick barge. Topsides can be removed all in one piece, in groups of modules, reverse order of installation, or in small pieces.
If removing topsides in one piece, the derrick barge must have sufficient lifting capacity. This option is best used for small platforms. Also keep in mind the size and the crane capacity at the offloading site. If the offloading site can't accommodate the platform in one piece, then a different removal option is required.
Removing combined modules requires fewer lifts, thus is a time-saving option. However, the modules must be in the right position and have a combined weight under the crane and derrick barge capacity. Dismantling the topsides in reverse order in which they were installed, whether installed as modules or as individual structural components, is another removal option and the most common.
Topside can also be cut into small pieces and removed with platform cranes, temporary deck mounted cranes, or other small (less expensive) cranes. However, this method takes the most time to complete the job, so any cost savings incurred using a smaller derrick barge will likely be offset by the dayrate.
Removing the jacket is the second step in the demolition process and the most costly. First, divers using explosives, mechanical means, torches or abrasive technology make the bottom cuts on the piles 15 ft below the mudline. Then the jacket is removed either in small pieces or as a single lift. A single lift is possible only for small structures in less than 200 ft of water. Heavy lifting equipment is required for the jacket removal as well, but a derrick barge is not necessary. Less expensive support equipment can do the job.
Pipeline And Power Cable Decommissioning
Pipelines or power cables may be decommissioned in place if they do not interfere with navigation or commercial fishing operations or pose an environmental hazard. However, if the BOEMRE rules that it is a hazard during the technical and environmental review during the permitting process, it must be removed.
The first step to pipeline decommissioning in place requires a flushing it with water followed by disconnecting it from the platform and filling it with seawater. The open end is plugged an buried 3 ft below the seafloor and covered with concrete.
Materials Disposal And Site Clearance
Platform materials can be refurbished and reused, scrapped and recycled or disposed of in specified landfills.
To ensure proper site clearance, operators need to follow a four-step site clearance procedure.
  1. Pre-decommissioning survey maps the location and quantity of debris, pipelines, power cables, and natural marine environments.
  2. Post decommissioning survey identifies debris left behind during the removal process and notes any environmental damage
  3. ROVs and divers target are deployed to further identify and remove any debris that could interfere with other uses of the area.
  4. Test trawling verifies that the area is free of any potential obstructions.
ROVs and divers target are deployed


Sumber: http://www.rigzone.com/training/insight.asp?i_id=354

Pipeline Construction

Designing large-diameter pipelines for deepwater installation

Upcoming South Stream project in Black Sea calls for 560 mi of 32-in. pipe in depths to 7,200 ft 
Gazprom has successfully realized some of the world's largest offshore gas transportation systems, with pipelines in the 24-in. (61-cm) diameter range traversing water depths of more than 2,100 m (6,889 ft) with the Blue Stream I and II projects.
Now, with South Stream, project planners are considering the challenges of installing 32-in. (81-cm) diameter pipeline in depths that will exceed 2,200 m (7,200 ft). The 900-km (560-mi) pipeline will extend from the Russian coast to a western landfall on either the Bulgarian or Romanian coastline. Some of the key challenges include:
  • Water depths exceeding 2,200 m (7,200 ft)
  • Relatively large pipeline diameter for given water depth
  • Difficult seabed conditions with steep slopes and geohazards
  • Potentially aggressive/corrosive subsea environments.
The complexity of an offshore pipeline typically is expressed in terms of the water depth and diameter. While these are not the only drivers for a project's complexity, this expression does provide a good insight in the position of a project in relation to the current status of the industry.
While a 24-in. pipeline in 2,150 m (7,053 ft) as installed for Blue Stream in 2003 was a major challenge at the time, that project did lead to the development of technology that is now considered proven, and similar projects have been realized in various regions in the world. With projects like South Stream, the industry is now exploring a new frontier and preparing for the next step.

Seabed conditions

Pipelines across the Black Sea need to traverse a deep abyssal plain bordered by steep and sometimes rugged continental slopes. While the deepwater of the abyssal plain leads to a high external pressure, which is important for the wall thickness requirement, the continental slope crossings also can be challenging, often with high risk of pipeline spanning and geohazards.
Offshore section of the South Stream project.
In deepwater, the current and wave effects are limited, causing little dynamic loading. Allowable pipeline spans are typically longer than in shallow water and governed by local buckling criteria. Excessive spans can be corrected either by shoulder shaving, support placements, or combination thereof; the tooling for both seabed intervention methods has been developed and is available.
Geohazards are defined as features of the natural seabed that threaten the integrity of submarine pipeline systems. Such features include submarine channels, faulting, unstable slopes, landslides, mud volcanoes, seabed hydrates, pockmarks, debris, and turbidity flows.
Historically, the risk posed by such features has been eliminated often simply by routing around them. However, for pipelines crossing a continental slope into deepwater, it becomes less likely that all such potential hazards can be avoided. Hence, engineering solutions must take into account the underlying geological and/or sediment movement processes.
Geohazards can lead to significant loads on or displacements of a pipeline. In the Black Sea, the most relevant geohazards include:
  • Faults
  • Unstable slopes resulting in slumps or slides
  • Mudflows / mass gravity flows
  • Earthquake or wave induced liquefaction in the shore approach area
  • Mud volcanoes
  • Gas-expulsion features.
All of the above features have been identified in the project area, and need to be addressed through rigorous survey and engineering. Earthquake-induced slope stability and mass gravity flows could pose a significant risk to the integrity of the pipeline at the Russian continental slope, and a similar situation exists for the western continental margin. An extensive feasibility survey has been performed to identify these risks and to develop preliminary route options. To further quantify these risks, it is important to perform a comprehensive design survey campaign to capture and analyze these geohazards. This can save a significant amount of time/costs on subsequent detailed surveys, studies, and construction.
It is one of the best-known Black Sea properties: deeper than approximately 150 to 200 m (490 to 656 ft), Black Sea water does not contain oxygen, but does contain dissolved sulfuric hydride. Water mixing (driven by currents and waves) is needed for the oxygen captured from air and generated by algae at the sea surface to reach lower layers of the sea. In the Black Sea, there is extremely little vertical water mixing, resulting in the world's largest stratified water body.
For the Blue Stream project, the environment of the Black Sea was classified as sour (or “H2S containing”) based on extensive measurement campaigns and supported by historical research data that showed accelerated corrosion rates in parts of the Black Sea environment. The likely cause of the corrosion was identified as a combination of H2S and sulphate reducing bacteria (SRB). Detailed water and soil tests are being performed for the South Stream project to establish the chemistry of the Black Sea environment over the vertical water column, as well as the top soil to a depth of 4 to 6 m (13 to 19.7 ft) below the seabed surface.
Contrary to normal sour service pipelines in which sour medium is introduced inside of the pipe, the Black Sea environment may cause H2S exposure to the outer surface of the pipe. This service condition applies over the system lifetime. It is difficult to quantify, since it depends on highly localized soil conditions and pipe/soil/water chemical interactions over the complete length and lifetime of the system. When present, high H2S concentration is typically found at a depth of 2 to 4 m (6.5 to 13 ft) below the seabed. Its effects on the pipe steel and welds are being investigated.
Since there are no concepts readily available to mitigate an external H2S-containing environment after pipeline operation, it is essential to correctly assess the associated risks and costs. For South Stream, this issue is being investigated in detail through an extensive geochemical survey and analysis program, as well as a detailed material testing and development program.

Hydraulic performance

For a project like South Stream, the investment involved is considerable and the ability to transport significantly more gas at limited additional cost improves the commercial performance of the project. Hence, an increase in diameter has significant benefits for the project economics, enabling more gas to be transported over longer distances. As part of project analysis, planners have examined the typical relationship between inlet pressure and outside diameter for different throughputs for a 900-km (560-mi) pipeline. The research showed that a diameter increase from 24 to 32-in. allows twice the volume of gas to be transported. While the friction loss increases exponentially for smaller diameters, it also increases with the higher velocities required to transport the same volume through a smaller pipe. While this figure only relates to a typical pipeline length, the same considerations apply for shorter distance pipelines, justifying the desire to implement larger diameter pipelines for deep water application. For inlet pressure requirements up to 30 MPa (4,350 psi), the application of existing and field proven technologies is available. No technology gap is foreseen.
For pipelines as long as South Stream, the minimum allowable arrival temperature requirement can become the governing factor rather than the pressure loss. The gas cools when ascending the continental slope and passing through the buried shore approach section on the receiving end. Good knowledge of pipeline settlement (and therefore soil conditions) and concrete coating becomes important to accurately predict the hydraulic performance of the system. In case that the in-situ sediment at the downstream shore approach is found to be susceptible to frost heave, it would be wise to consider engineered backfill.
The parameter that strongly influences the system's thermo-hydraulic performance is the embedment on the continental shelf at the receiving end. Overall, embedment in the soft, often liquid clay of the Black Sea can easily be 50 to 100% or more of the diameter. Thermo-hydraulic performance is verified against existing operational information to provide additional certainty; given the importance of pipe burial, the hydraulic analyses will be revisited after geotechnical survey results are obtained and pipe burial has been calculated.
Another parameter influencing the receiving temperature is the application of concrete coating. Concrete coating provides a thermal insulation in comparison to an uncoated pipe. One option being considered is to continue the deepwater wall thickness up to the receiving landfall, thereby reducing the extent of concrete coated pipe. While this would most likely result in a higher capex, the overall throughput capacity could be improved.

Steel grade selection

It is generally practical to apply the highest possible line pipe grade to minimize the wall thickness, weight, and cost of the pipeline. For deepwater offshore applications, DNV SAWL 450 has been used in numerous sour and non-sour conditions. DNV SAWL 485 grade has been produced almost exclusively for non-sour service, although recent developments and trials in sour service conditions have been initiated for small-diameter pipelines. Nevertheless, additional qualifications for H2S-resistant application are required to ensure the performance of DNV SAWL 485.
Full-scale collapse test rig.

Installability

The combination of pipeline diameter and maximum water depth for South Stream exceeds that previously achieved in the worldwide pipeline industry. The first issue to be addressed in terms of overall construction feasibility is, therefore, the ability to install the selected pipeline dimensions in the deepwater segment of the route.
Furthermore, the significant route length introduces additional challenges to maximize installation efficiency. Installation of the pipeline will require extension of the existing global pipelay installation capacity. In doing so, the success factors and experiences from previous record-setting pipeline projects such as Blue Stream and Nord Stream must be evaluated and applied where appropriate.
The feasibility of the installation of the deepwater section of the route governs the overall system construction feasibility. As part of this process, the capabilities of the existing deepwater pipeline installation vessels are being assessed against the deepwater installation requirements on this project. The three existing deepwater pipeline installation vessels usually considered suitable for a project like South Stream are the Saipem S7000, Allseas Solitaire, and HMC Balder. Furthermore, the deepwater installation capacity will increase in the future if several newbuild vessels are completed on schedule. These include the Saipem FDS-2 and Castorone; the Allseas Pieter Schelte, and a new vessel being developed by Hereema Marine Contractors (HMC). In general, it has been concluded that installation is feasible using the existing deepwater installation vessel fleet. However, the assessment of the existing three deepwater pipeline installation vessels shows that all three vessels will require some modifications/upgrades to install the South Stream system safely and efficiently.

Wall thickness

Core to the capability to develop large diameter projects in deepwater is the wall thickness design in combination with the manufacturability of the linepipe.
Full-scale collapse test pipe.
For the pipe diameter and wall thickness under discussion, only two pipe manufacturing processes are feasible: JCOE and UOE.
In the JCOE process, the plate is formed to a J-shape using a pressed module, step-by-step at a fixed width interval. Then using a similar method, the plate is formed to a C-shape until it obtains an O-shape. The pipe is subjected to cold expansion after tack weld and submerged arc welded at the inside and outside parts.
The UOE process consists of forming the plate into U-shape and O-shape using a pressed module, followed by tack weld and longitudinal weld of the pipe. As opposed to the JCOE process, both the U-shape and O-shape are obtained using one-step forming. Thereafter the pipe is cold expanded to obtain the required dimension. For both pipe manufacturing methods, the current DNV code formulation results in a reduction of the compressive strength after the manufacturing process, with 15% compared with tensile strength.
The wall thickness required for South Stream is at the limit of the leading mills' capability. One limitation for some mills is the capacity of the pipe-forming process (such as the capacity of the O-press). While this restriction may be avoided through a considerable investment in upgrade of the mill, the control of pipe properties in the weld area for such thick-walled pipes remains a major issue (in particular parameters such as ductility and toughness). For deepwater application, these pipe properties are critical to the pipe performance. Achieving the desired material parameters for the wall thickness required using standard calculation methods is on the edge of what can be produced. A small reduction in wall thickness can result in a major improvement in manufacturability, and thereby drive the actual feasibility of the project for a specific throughput and OD combination.
For the deepwater section of the pipeline, the design is governed by the local buckling criterion. This condition occurs during installation at the pipeline sagbend where the pipeline will experience the most extreme combination of external pressure and bending. In the calculation of the required wall thickness for this design limit state, the following critical technological advances can be applied:
  • Recovery of collapse resistance through thermal aging
  • Tighter dimensional control on line pipe manufacture
  • Tight control on bending strain during installation
  • A partly displacement-controlled condition is applied in the design for the sagbend.
The largest contribution to wall thickness optimization is from the recovery of collapse resistance through thermal aging. Pipe collapse resistance is linked to the pipe hoop compressive strength. Many studies including small-scale and full-scale tests have been performed in the past 20 years (for example Oman-India, Blue Stream, and Mardi Gras), evidencing that a significant recovery in collapse strength can be gained for DNV SAWL 450 steel (in the order of 30%). In fact, test results suggest the collapse resistance is recovered even beyond the original value.
Using the current DNV F101 formulation, most mills, nowadays, indicate that they are able to produce pipe with a significantly improved fabrication factor, incorporating strength recovery through thermal aging. Thermal aging effect is the ability of steel to recover its strength due to strain aging. It is possible to take advantage of thermal aging through application of external coating, which usually takes place at the same temperature range as where the thermal aging process occurs.
For a deepwater, large-diameter pipeline such as South Stream, using a thinner wall without compromising system reliability is desirable not only for the obvious economics in steel saving but also out of necessity, as blind compliance to the current international design codes would result in a wall thickness that is beyond manufacturability.
To give the owner, designer, and manufacturer sufficient confidence, Gazprom has commissioned a full testing program, which is currently ongoing. This testing program includes full scale testing of as-received and thermally treated pipe joints, subjected to combined loading of external pressure and bending.

Deepwater repair contingencies

In the past, even though the probability of failure of a properly planned deepwater pipeline is small, the risk associated has been a concern because of the difficulties in making repairs. While the effort required remains considerable, current deepwater technology provides the tooling that allows repairs large-diameter, deepwater pipelines. Even within the region, repair systems are available for the water depth (Blue Stream) or diameter (Green Stream) under discussion. To combine these into a new application is relatively straightforward, with little technology gap.

Conclusions

A 24-in. pipeline in 2,150-m water depth or 32-in. pipelines in 1,400-m water depth are accepted by the offshore industry as proven technologies. The South Stream project is now investigating the feasibility of using larger diameters (such as 32-in.) in 2,200-m-plus water depths, and its successful construction will be another step-change for the offshore industry. The use of a larger diameter will provide obvious benefits for the project economics, allowing a considerably higher throughput; but this requires an advance application of existing technologies.
For the present installation fleet, the installability of such a pipeline is complex but not governing. This capability will be further improved if the currently scheduled deepwater installation vessels are completed on schedule. Still, rigorous design is essential, regardless of the selected diameter.
Key to the success of such projects is the manufacturability of the line pipe with the requisite wall thickness. The wall thickness required for large-diameter pipelines is on the edge of leading mills' capabilities. Several technology advances need to be applied to achieve feasibility, and a rigorous development program is ongoing for successful implementation.
Sumber: http://www.offshore-mag.com/articles/print/volume-71/issue-8/flowlines-__pipelines/designing-large-diameter-pipelines-for-deepwater-installation.html